The negative income tax (NIT) sometimes seems like the carbon tax of social policy. Both are irresistibly appealing to economists and have long pedigrees. Both are supported by blindingly persuasive logic. Yet neither policy seems capable of mustering much political support in 21st-century Washington politics. I see two things as essential in repackaging the NIT for today’s America.
The first essential is to recognize
the reality of path dependency — the need to start from where we are, not from
a clean slate, and take things one step at a time. Gerald Gaus calls that approach “exploring the
adjacent possible.”
The second essential is to present the NIT in a
value framework that has broad appeal across the political spectrum. As things
stand, the NIT has about an even balance of progressive and conservative
skeptics, yet properly implemented, it offers much that is in harmony with the
values of both sides.
Here, then, are some ideas for nudging the NIT along from a merely an elegant concept toward something more concrete and workable.
